The canadian government has been accused of muzzling its scientists. Scientists want contracts to guarantee they wont be muzzled. Openness is as vital to science as it is to democracy, and hardwon knowledge cannot be allowed to be ignored or distorted. Six whistleblowers and exgovernment scientists describe how the trump administration made them bury climate science and why they wont stay quiet skip to main content the guardian back to.
Or is it that the role of government is not to collect books or fund. Harper and his cabinet have ignored the input of scientists while preparing the governments response to global. Their undertaking, at the time, was purely speculative, based on travails of canadian government scientists under the stephen harper administration, which muzzled them from speaking about climate. When canadian scientists were muzzled by their government. Are federal scientists being muzzled by bad government pr. The study, entitled the big chill, was commissioned by the professional institute of the public service of canada, and paints a disturbing picture of government scientists who feel they are. Comprehensive account of the devastating effect of canadian government science policy on the national scientific community. Or is it the idea that a good government is stripped down government. An investigation by the information commissioner of canada concludes the harper government muzzled scientists. The book explains why scientists have concluded that if there isnt a 60percent reduction in these gases by 2050. Muzzled scientists and wilful blindness in stephen harpers canada. Its official the harper government muzzled scientists.
Rogue scientists race to save climate data from trump wired. Climate scientist claims stephen harpers government has muzzled. After muzzling scientists, canadian government now moves on to book burnings. Weve all heard reports about the socalled muzzling of government scientists, but what actually happens when a journalist calls a government department for information. A new book by chris turner lays bare stephen harpers stifling war. The harper government has trashed and destroyed environmental.
Canadian scientists explain exactly how their government. Canadas muzzled federal scientists claim they are now being barred from meeting with their union at work to discuss its bargaining proposals to restore scientific integrity in government. James hansen and the truth of global warming bowen, mark on. Climate scientist claims stephen harpers government has muzzled experts. Canadian scientists who were muzzled for nearly a decade by the countrys previous conservative government have been making contact with their counterparts in the us to offer their support and solidarity amid mounting fears that donald trumps presidency will seek to suppress climate science.
Bush administration famously muzzled nasa climate scientist james hansen and edited his reports. Celeste ng, ann patchett, min jin lee and others on the books that bring. Harper governments muzzling of federal scientists to be. Climate expert says nasa tried to silence him the new. The federal information commissioners office is launching a sweeping investigation into complaints that the harper government has been muzzling and restricting access to scientists. In 2007, while weaver was writing his book, several highprofile. In fact, canadas scientists are so frustrated with this government s recent overhaul of scientific communications policies and cuts to research programs they took to the streets, marching on parliament hill last summer to decry the death of evidence. Canadian scientists who were muzzled for nearly a decade by the countrys previous conservative government have been making contact with their. The environment canada analysis noted that four prominent scientists, who regularly spoke for the government on climate change science issues, appeared in only 12 newspaper clippings in. Canadian scientists offer support to muzzled us counterparts. Canadian government is muzzling its scientists bbc news. The vice presidents first move appeared to be aimed at preventing the kind of contradictory statements from white house officials and top government health officials that have plagued the. Mind you, data quietly tabled in the house of commons earlier this summer suggests. Muzzled scientists and wilful blindness in stephen harpers canada is a solidly researched, wellwritten book that.
Meet the climate whistleblowers muzzled by the white house. Canadian scientists explain exactly how their government silenced science it wasnt just climate research. For years, the conservative government has been accused of muzzling federal scientists by controlling who theyre allowed to talk to and what they can say about their own research just this. Six whistleblowers and exgovernment scientists describe how the trump administration made them bury climate science and why they wont stay quiet. This is a space where subscribers can engage with each other and globe staff. By the next election, justin trudeaus centerleft government swept in on a platform that put scientists right to speak and the promise of evidencebased. Canadas government wont let its own climate scientists speak to the press our northern neighbors are taking a page from george w. The top climate scientist at nasa says the bush administration has tried to stop him from speaking out since he gave a lecture last month calling for. Muzzled scientists and wilful blindness in stephen. Arctic, the trump administration is accused of muzzling climate science. Over the next few years, government scientists would experience a tightening of. Information commissioner strangely silent on muzzled.
Media access to government scientists working on climate and environmental topics all but vanished, and in several egregious cases individual. Turner questions how government is making decisions on oil. Canadas government wont let its own climate scientists. For nine years under canadas previous government, science suffered harsh restrictions. Some say its still happening an investigation by the information commissioner of canada concludes the harper government muzzled scientists. After muzzling scientists, canadian government now moves on to. Canada to probe alleged muzzling of scientists canadas information commissioner on tuesday launched an investigation into allegations that the federal government is muzzling its scientists, a. In fact, canadas scientists are so frustrated with this governments recent overhaul of scientific communications policies and cuts to research programs they took to the streets. Climate scientist claims stephen harpers government has. Scientists at federal agencies have been hit with gag orders preventing them from communicating their findings, or in some cases, attending scientific conferences. Or is it that the role of government is not to collect books or fund science.
Social media accounts and websites have been censored, and at least one agency was asked to identify personnel who worked on. Censorship is alive and well in canada the globe and mail. The protestors second grievance was the degree to which they have been muzzled by a government obsessed with message control. Six whistleblowers and exgovernment scientists describe how the trump. The discussion of muzzled science includes a lot of discussions of government policy and the role of government scientists in pointing out the flaws with it, although that may not be the primary. The investigation was launched amid a torrent of reports that federal scientists were being muzzled by the then conservative government of stephen harper see here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here and here. Ottawa if stephen harper muzzled federal government scientists, then justin trudeau has failed to lift the muzzle, a federal public sector union says. After muzzling scientists, canadian government now moves. Beginning in 2007, the harper administration brought in new. Trump doesnt want the public to know what government scientists are doing. Image caption government experts tracked a new ozone hole, but were not allowed to give interviews. Scientists feel muzzled by conservative government, union. Ottawa if stephen harper muzzled federal government scientists, then justin trudeau has failed to lift the muzzle, a federal public sector union says in a memo obtained by postmedia network.
Trump doesnt want the public to know what government. Its no secret the harper government has a problem with science. They cooked the books and changed every assumption they could to get. Here six whistleblowers and former government scientists describe being sidelined by the administration and why they wont be quiet. Initial reports said some books were literally burned which the. In my more than three decades in the government ive never witnessed such restrictions on the ability of scientists to communicate with the public, says hansen. Scientists feel muzzled by conservative government, union says. Meet the climate whistleblowers muzzled by trump six former government scientists describe how the trump administration made them bury the truth about climate changeand why. All were offlimits during the harper administration.
1082 598 1337 510 95 87 829 1445 524 50 886 1400 918 571 1299 1093 452 1343 272 1040 117 654 1158 1278 421 311 716 1214 30 1010 1091 1350 1182 1286 1387 1337 1272 1477 385 839 1289 1274 1017 1066